Table of Contents
What are the criticisms of Jungian psychology?
Critics have accused Jung of metaphysical essentialism. His psychology, particularly his thoughts on spirit, lacked necessary scientific basis, making it mystical and based on foundational truth. Furthermore, they assert that his concept of archetypes are too vague to be studied systemically. ‘Dangerous Method’: Shocking Therapy For A Hysteric Freud’s attention was on the sexual underpinnings of — well, almost everything — and Jung was known for his mystical bent and dream theories. For years, the two were close friends and collaborators but they had a falling out that ultimately ended their relationship. Carl Jung’s most controversial idea was his belief in the existence of the collective unconscious. Freudian and Jungian theories are no longer held to the same rigorous standards as modern methods are, so they lose reputability in being go-to explanations for human behavior. Freud would be better to read first as he developed much of the basis of Jung’s work such as the unconscious; although they both have largely differing opinions on the unconscious. Jung described the animus as the unconscious masculine side of a woman, and the anima as the unconscious feminine side of a man, each transcending the personal psyche.
What are the criticisms of Jung?
Critics have accused Jung of metaphysical essentialism. His psychology, particularly his thoughts on spirit, lacked necessary scientific basis, making it mystical and based on foundational truth. Furthermore, they assert that his concept of archetypes are too vague to be studied systemically. Jungian therapy works with patients to help them recognize the potential in themselves and work toward personal growth. This holistic approach, which contains many spiritual elements, can help people see what obstacles have been preventing them from living fulfilled lives — and overcome them. Jung believed religion was a profound, psychological response to the unknown — both the inner self and the outer worlds — and he understood Christianity to be a profound meditation on the meaning of the life of Jesus of Nazareth within the context of Hebrew spirituality and the Biblical worldview. Jung thought of Freud as “extremely intelligent, shrewd and altogether remarkable,” and Freud considered Jung his peer, even calling him “my eldest son,” and deeming him heir to his psychoanalytic process. Jung (1948) disagreed with Freud regarding the role of sexuality. He believed the libido was not just sexual energy, but instead generalized psychic energy.
Is Jungian psychology effective?
A recent meta-analysis of empirical studies on the outcomes of Jungian therapy reports that many find success with the treatment, finding “significant improvements” of symptoms and interpersonal problems. Process studies support Jungian theories on psychodynamics and elements of change in the therapeutic process. So finally, Jungian psychotherapy has reached the point where it can be called an empirically proven, effective method. It remains the treatment of choice for some personality disorders and other chronic, unrelenting psychiatric syndromes. Recent research has shown psychoanalytic psychotherapy to be as or more effective than other forms of psychotherapy for a range of psychiatric conditions. But while Jung clearly used Nietzsche as part of his critique of Freudian psychoanalysis, he began to view both Nietzsche and Freud as too materialistic in their psychology, to the point where he, Jung, viewed Nietzsche’s “spectacular failure to negotiate with Dionysos” as pointing the way to his own “more successful … Perhaps the greatest disadvantage of psychoanalysis and related approaches is the lack of empirical support for their effectiveness. The limited research that has been conducted on these treatments suggests that they do not reliably lead to better mental health outcomes (e.g., Driessen et al., 2010). JUNG met Freud for the first time in 1907 in Vienna. The two spent more than 12 hours together, en grossed in conversation. Jung was bursting to talk and flooded Freud with ideas and observations.
What were the major controversies between Jung and Freud?
Freud, in particular, was unhappy with Jung’s disagreement with some of the key concepts and ideas of Freudian theory. For example, Jung disagreed with Freud’s focus on sexuality as a key motivating behavioural force, as well as believing Freud’s concept of the unconscious as too limited and overly negative. Freud’s psychoanalytic theory has been highly criticized for its dependency on case studies, lack of empirical evidence, and its lack of a strictly scientific approach. The relationship between Sigmund Freud and C. G. Jung had its bright beginning in 1906 and came to its embittered end in 1913. Two common criticisms, espoused by laypeople and professionals alike, are that the theory is too simple to ever explain something as complex as a human mind, and that Freud overemphasized sex and was unbalanced here (was sexist). Many objections have been leveled against traditional psychoanalysis, both for its methodological rigidity and for its lack of theoretical rigor. A number of modern psychologists have pointed out that traditional psychoanalysis relies too much on ambiguities for its data, such as dreams and free associations.
What do Jungians believe?
According to Jung’s teachings, the collective unconscious is common to all human beings. 1 Jung also believed that the collective unconscious is responsible for a number of deep-seated beliefs and instincts, such as spirituality, sexual behavior, and life and death instincts. Freud would be better to read first as he developed much of the basis of Jung’s work such as the unconscious; although they both have largely differing opinions on the unconscious. Why did Jung wish to avoid the terms mind and mental? a) He felt that they implied consciousness. Jungian therapy works with patients to help them recognize the potential in themselves and work toward personal growth. This holistic approach, which contains many spiritual elements, can help people see what obstacles have been preventing them from living fulfilled lives — and overcome them. Second, Jung asserts that since God is an archetype we are forced to think of God as relative. Thus, God is as dependent upon man as man is upon God. Third, the essential aspect of the concept of God is wholeness or completeness. Therefore, He is both good and evil, darkness as well as light. The professional fission supposedly began when Jung’s theory about the psychology of the unconscious and sexuality diverged from Freud’s thinking about psychoanalysis.
What are the two major attitudes according to Jung?
Jung Personality Types theory In addition, he distinguishes between two fundamental life attitudes: introversion and extraversion. Written and verified by the psychologist Valeria Sabater. The INFJ personality, a unique combination of the psychological traits of introversion, intuition, feeling and judgment, represents — according to Carl Jung — only 1% of the population. The final stage, transformation, was described by Jung as being similar to self-actualization. Also like self-actualization, not every patient (or person) makes it to this stage. Jung did not believe in astrology 3, i.e., belief as acceptance or faith in something as true, although materially unprovable. Based on his experience of acausal phenomena when using analysands’ natal charts, Jung knew that the irrational was operative in astrology, as it is in tarot and I Ching. One of the central disagreements between Jung and Freud was their differing conceptions of the unconscious. Freud’s Position: Freud believed the unconscious mind was the epicentre of our repressed thoughts, traumatic memories, and fundamental drives of sex and aggression.